“Buffalo Zine is back and it’s better than ever. In an all-out issue shot entirely in the mag’s east London office building, its creators have brought together a bevy of talent that includes everyone from Pamela Anderson to David Bailey. Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales and cult icon Judy Blame also features in the issue, along with model-turned-actress Lily Cole, Lennon Gallagher, rising model and son of Liam, curator Hans Ulrich-Obrist and philosopher Michel Serres.”
— DAZED
“Trends go one way and Buffalo marches resolutely off in the opposite direction. It’s a formula that works: five issues in and we’re still hooked.”
— IT'S NICE THAT 
“Do you like fun, innovative, exciting, joyful, beautiful, and magical magazines? Do you like your fashion thought provoking, intellectually stimulating and visually arresting? You do? Well you are in luck, because the most fun, the most exciting, the most magical of magazines is back for their fifth issue. And boy have the boys from Buffalo Zine outdone themselves again. Somehow it just keeps on getting better and better. In fact, if we didn’t work here, we’d work there if they’d have us.”
— i-D
“Brilliant, quite unlike anything else being done today. The arrival of a new issue of Buffalo Zine is always an exciting moment, promising some exhilarating magazine-making.”
— MAGCULTURE